Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 55:09 — 37.9MB)
Subscribe to #SAnow RSS | Subscribe to #SAnow Podcast
What happens when the work you love asks you to compromise the values that brought you into student affairs?
In today’s higher education landscape, many student affairs practitioners face competing demands, limited resources, and institutional decisions that can leave them feeling ethically conflicted and emotionally exhausted. This experience, known as moral suffering, is an increasingly important conversation for the profession.
In this episode, host Dr. Glenn DeGuzman is joined by Drs. Jason Lynch (Appalachian State University), Mays Imad (Connecticut College), and Jonathan O’Brien (California State University Long Beach) to explore what moral suffering looks like in student affairs, why it happens, and how practitioners and leaders can recognize and respond to it with greater awareness and compassion.
This discussion will explore what moral suffering looks like in the day-to-day realities of student affairs, why it has become so prevalent in today’s higher education landscape, and how practitioners and leaders can recognize, respond to, and move through these experiences with greater awareness and compassion.
Whether you’ve ever felt caught between institutional expectations and your own professional values, struggled with the emotional weight of difficult decisions, or wondered how to sustain yourself while continuing to serve students, this episode offers language, insight, and hope for navigating one of the profession’s most pressing challenges.
DeGuzman, G. (Host). (2026, November 18). When Doing the Right Thing Hurts: Understanding Moral Suffering in Student Affairs (No. 369) [Audio podcast episode]. In Student Affairs NOW. https://studentaffairsnow.com/when-doing-the-right-thing-hurts/
Mays Imad: And I think it’s important to make a distinction between burnout, which is, you know, has many dimensions and it’s related to work, and with, with moral distress or moral injury or moral, um, wounds, which really are relational and pertain to our sense of meaning. Mm. And it’s asking a different question. It’s asking us to, or it’s putting me in a position to ask, what have I been asked to compromise? And what have I witnessed and not said anything or… So ultimately, when I think of m- these moral arenas, distress, wounds, uh, fragmentation and so on, I think that moral injury injures trust.
Glenn DeGuzman: Hello and welcome to Student Affairs NOW. My name is Glenn DeGuzman. I’m calling Zooming in from UC Berkeley in California. This episode is taking place on the traditional ancestral lands of the Ohlone peoples, where we extend our respect to the elders past and present, and to all indigenous people.
Student Affairs NOW is the premier podcast and online learning community for those of us who work in, alongside, and adjacent to the field of higher education and student affairs. We release new episodes every week on Wednesdays. Find details about this episode or browse our archives at studentaffairsnow.com.
This episode is sponsored by Evolve. Evolve offers four leadership coaching journeys designed to expand capacity and build capabilities, empowering courageous leadership to transform institutions and reimagine the future of higher education So I’m super excited about today’s topic because it is about moral suffering, and to explore what moral suffering looks like in a student affairs context, why it happens, and how practitioners and leaders can recognize and respond to it with greater awareness and compassion.
As a leader myself, I know I struggled, and oftentimes just recognize, respond to, and just move through these feelings and experiences with greater awareness leveraging my skill and compassion, but I know it’s a very challenging thing. So I have invited an e- expert panel to today’s podcast to help me and to those in our field of student affairs to share some insight and lend their expertise in managing institutional expectations and our own moral values and convictions.
So joining us today, super excited about this, we have Dr. Mays Imad, Doctors Jason Lynch, and Dr. Jonathan O’Brien. So let’s get to know them a little bit better. If you could just quickly introduce yourself feel to expand a little bit more about what you you do, your research and interests, and let’s start with Jonathan.
Jonathan O’Brien: Hi, Jonathan. And hi to the panel. Yeah, I’m Jonathan O’Brien. I’m a professor at California State University in Long Beach. I teach law and ethics there and qualitative research. Before faculty life, I was an administrator for about 15 years and worked in a lot of functional areas. I guess the research questions guiding my research are generally, what’s the difference between principled moral evolution and more performative virtue?
And I like to study how leaders can maintain authenticity while they’re adapting to shifting ideological contexts. So came from my own experience, and I’m excited to be on the panel. Thank you.
Glenn DeGuzman: Happy to have you on the panel, Jonathan. Jason?
Jason Lynch: Hi, friends. Again, thank you to everybody for having me.
So my name’s Jason Lynch. I am an associate professor of higher education and student affairs, and newly appointed program director for our MA program at Appalachian State in Boone, North Carolina. A lot of my research in teaching and service interests lie around issues of traumatic stress in higher education and how that intersects with workplace wellbeing.
Pretty much everything I do try to, tries to center around how do we make more humane workspaces for our staff and faculty colleagues, and I believe that trickles down to our students as well. And like Jonathan, I spent about a decade in practice as a student affairs practitioner. Glenn was actually one of my big supervisors back in the day w- when I worked in residence life, but have worked in other functional areas as well, and that work has led me to what I study today.
Glenn DeGuzman: Jason, congratulations on that, that post, and thank you for pointing out that I’m old. Jason, you’ve been on the, the podcast in the past, so it’s wonderful to always have you back. And Mays, please tell us a little bit more about yourself.
Mays Imad: Hello. Hello, everyone. Thank you for having me on this panel.
My name is Mays Imad. I am an educator. I’m a neuroscientist. Currently, I am at Connecticut College in the biology department, and I direct the neuroscience program I have spent m- much of my life trying to understand how do we, how do humans make sense of the world, make meaning and not just sense of the world outside, but our inner world.
And so I look at the emotions and regulations and learning, the social determinants of learning, and also structures that is structures and conditions. What conditions and structures do institut- institutions have that either stifle human becoming or enable and cultivate human becoming?
And one of the things that more recently I have been looking into is how do we make sense of when the things, when the work that I do and love so much becomes also a site where I am asked to compromise my values? And so this is one of the questions that I’m working with students and with colleagues to trying to trouble and understand.
Yeah.
Glenn DeGuzman: Thank you, Mays. So I’m gonna start, and this quest- really I wanna provide context for our listeners and those watching on YouTube. This whole… I’d never heard of moral suffering until Jason Jonathan, you sent me an article. And I was like, “W- this is amazing.” E- your work and the in- for- the, you gave me, you gave language for an experience that I suspect that many student affairs professionals like myself felt but may have not known how to name it.
So let’s get us all s- on the same baseline here. What is moral suffering, and how is it distinct from burnout and compassion fatigue or ordinary work stress? Because that’s maybe how, where I started. I’m thinking, “Isn’t this workplace stress?” So help me find language here. Jason, Jonathan, who wants to take the lead on this one?
Jason Lynch: Maybe I’ll provide a succinct thought and then Jonathan and Mays can make it more nuanced perhaps, right? So I just view moral suffering as a mismatch between, your personal values and your job’s sort of responsibility. So those things don’t always align, and sometimes no matter what your values are, they could fall on a spectrum of things, right?
But if your job is requiring you to do something that is against those values, then that creates some dissonance. And depending on the severity of that it could lead to various forms of suffering. And for me, things like burnout, secondary trauma, compassion fatigue, all those things are sort of outcomes.
And for me, like moral suffering is almost more of a context that leads to these other things as well. So I’ll throw the ball over to my colleagues to see if they can make it sound better.
Jonathan O’Brien: Sure. I will, I’ll go ahead. Yeah, no I think I would agree with Jason, and I would just even further draw the distinction between burnout, which is, I think, very common discussion right now in the field- … but that moral suffering also has a, a real, a deep history and tradition.
And it’s across multiple helping professions, and it’s really what happens when people with great compassion to help and assist and others grow often find that those opportunities are blocked. And as a result, it costs real alienation between the individual and their work.
And I find that to be one of the things that’s a hallmark of it, as opposed to just burnout, which often can be cured with some rest and time away.
Glenn DeGuzman: Jonathan, I read your article, and for those who are new to our podcast any, any topic subjects that we discuss and we reference articles and whatnot, it’s at the…
Go to our website. It’s it’s all cited, so if you wanna follow up and do more research on your own please do but I read your article on moral positionality and polar- polarization. That resonated with me ’cause your work on moral positionality explores the different ways educational leaders understand and approach moral questions.
So how do student affairs professionals’ moral orientation shape the way they interpret difficult decisions the institutional constraints that we face, or even the competing responsibilities?
Jonathan O’Brien: Yeah, absolutely. Thank you for allowing me to expand a bit on that. It’s a, to some degree, a precursor because I- I have four moral positions that I describe.
And these came out of observation and also literature, but those frames are essentially positions. I call them positions. They’re places that you can stand, but they’re positions, so you can shift.
And those positions are equity, which centers care attentive to power- … who might be harmed by an outcome that a, a leader might be making or a, a professional.
Besides equity, there’s also compliance. Compliance is often related to the rules. It’s related to regulations and institutional or external expectations that we’re required to do in our job. The other one is strategy. It’s very pragmatic. It’s really the, the ethics of weighing what is possible given the power dynamics, the structures, the political conditions that we operate in.
And the fourth position is authority, and this is really the one that respects your personal values, your convictions the things that you can stand behind, kind of your red line that you will not cross. What I would say is that when we’re making tough decisions, we often shift among those positions.
And so what I mean by that is, you might begin with an equity position. You might say to yourself, like “Who’s gonna be harmed in this situation?” But then you need to move into compliance because in, as an institutional representative, it’s like you’ve gotta be attentive to whatever rules are involved.
But then we often filter that through an ethics of strategy. Okay what can I do though to be able to get the best possible outcome for the student or the individual while still balancing the need to follow rules? And finally, authority is that last position that we take where we’re like, “Okay, so can I stand by this?
Like, when I actually make that decision, can I live with this? Can I put my head on the pillow at night and sleep comfortably enough?” And I think central to the process I’ve found in my research is moral courage, and so that’s just that capacity to act in alignment with your convictions, right?
Despite the po- the possibility that there’s personal or professional risk.
And what I would say is today we’re facing a lot of political polarization, and that’s really testing our ability to move among these positions in the way that is natural to us. A lot of institutions are requiring practitioners to occupy positions that they would reject as immoral in any other situation, right?
They’re being compelled to do things in order to keep their job, to keep their health benefits. So that sets them up in a really difficult position. So movement among those positions might look like, moral growth to the individual, but to others it might look like you’re a chameleon just shifting to keep your job.
And that puts you in real tension, right? Practitioners can only absorb so many ethical compromises before ultimately they begin to lose their moral footing, right? And then when that happens, you really find a gap between institutional authorities requiring you to do certain things and your own moral professional responsibility to do what you believe is right.
And so recently, actually, my colleague Cecilia Lopez and I have been looking at what that gap is. And so that’s kind of part of the whole strategy. But all of this, missteps actually I think are a precursor to what we ultimately think of here as moral suffering.
Glenn DeGuzman: Just a sort of a comment to what you just said.
I also think, I wonder how years of experience or where you’re at, like positionally in your career, I imagine a newer professional, someone new they might feel locked in. Like they might not be able to act with courage on certain things as maybe somebody who’s further along. Or even just the awareness or the capacity of the experiences that they’ve gained.
And so it may shift and shape some folks’ like interpretation of what they’re going through, right?
Jonathan O’Brien: Absolutely. I tell my students who are in graduate programs, and I also have doctoral students who have been working in the field for a while, I often tell my newer professionals in the grad program and the masters, “Hey, your courage might look more like bravery.”
Like just showing up, like just witnessing people’s trauma, people’s experiences, and doing what you can, because it’s not your job to necessarily step out and then put yourself in ethical risk. But I tell my ed leaders, the ones who have been working in the field 15 years or more, for them I say, “Bravery for you is integrity.
People are watching you.” You are the role model. And whether you like it or not, your new professionals, your staff are looking at you to be that, that moral guideline, right? That person that is like, you are the face of the culture and what that culture- allows or permits with regard to what’s ethical ar- around here, in the institution.
Glenn DeGuzman: And that’s real. Let’s ex- let’s extend that. Jason, from your perspective, what organizational conditions and as a department leader I think what will intensify moral suffering for student affairs professionals, particularly at leadership level?
Jason Lynch: Yeah, certainly. I think that we have some data that we’ve Jonathan and I collected that we’re parsing through right now.
We had a survey that went out, and we had about 330 student affairs professionals from across the country that filled it out. And some of the things that we found were how folks were perceiving immoral context, right? And what, like, how is it that they’re viewing the moral situation?
Because not everybody views the same situation through the same moral lens, right? And so it has a lot to do with their values and whatnot. But I think part of what we’ve discovered and where I connect in with this is around ideas of organizational trauma and and personal workplace trauma, right?
Is your ability to enact, enact agency, right? And mentioned younger professionals. And younger professionals don’t really know how to enact agency yet, right? And perceive themselves as not having agency because they’re at the very lower levels of the organization, and they perceive the upper level administration as having a lot of agency.
But that’s also not necessarily true, depending on what their positionality is, right? And so I think the, whenever staff members feel that either they can’t express how they are being impacted, if they’re perceiving their upper level administration, their supervisors, as either not caring or not engaging these conversations, all of those things tend to lend towards silence, right?
And then silence is what kind of expands on this. And so yeah, so I think that those are a couple things that, that that come to mind.
Glenn DeGuzman: Yeah. And just, hurt is hurt, right? And so Mays, this question for you is when people experience a sustained conflict between what they believe is right and what they f- what they feel they are able or required to do, there is obviously an emotional cause.
And in your article I, Moral Wounds wonderful article. It’s… Look at it. It’s in the resources, people. You describe moral injury as more than a private experience, that it can become a social and relational wound. Can you help our listeners understand what happens to individuals in campus communities when moral suffering or moral injury just goes unnamed and unaddressed?
Mays Imad: Thank you. So I often tell my students that our nervous system is embodied, and that embodied nervous system you could think of it as a meaning-making, predicting machine.
We seek information from the environment, from our external and internal environment, from our peers, from others to build a mental model that predicts my safety, my connection, my identity, and we have meaning.
We’ve made meaning about life and about my inner life, my outer life, and so on So these things I talk about, whether it’s moral injury or burnout, those are… I think of them as the nervous system, that embodied nervous system acting in a way that is adaptive and protective.
It’s giving us information.
It’s saying that, in the case of burnout it’s saying that, “I have worked too much. I can’t do it.” And of course, this is I’m using the I, but it’s more than the I. It’s the system, it’s the-
And I think it’s important to make a distinction between burnout, which is, has many dimensions and it’s related to work, and with moral distress or moral injury or moral wounds, which really are relational and pertain to our sense of meaning.
And it’s asking a different question. It’s asking us to, or it’s putting me in a position to ask, what have I been asked to compromise? And what have I witnessed and not said anything or… So ultimately, when I think of m- these moral arenas, distress, wounds fragmentation and so on, I think that moral injury injures trust.
Trust between me and myself. Did I betray my value? Trust between me and others. Did I betray others, or have others betrayed me with their silence or with their I don’t know, accommodation? And then what about the institution? And for example, when I’ve worked with students and I have done research with students, the perspective of students when it comes to these moral dimensions, yes, there is mental health and anxiety, and they are burnt out and so on, but when you dig deeper, students, at least the ones I’ve worked with, interviewed, will say that w- what they’re describing is a sense of betrayal.
They came to an institution under some assumption, some meaning, some mental model, and at one point they realize they are just numbers.
That’s… I say that breaks the heart. And when we don’t name the distinction, when we just say it’s a burnout or it’s, it’s lack of resilience, then it- the onus remains on the individual, and we don’t really take responsibility or address or even start looking at micro repairs possibilities.
Glenn DeGuzman: Mayz, I wanna expand on that. Oh, go ahead, Jason.
Jason Lynch: Oh, yeah. I was… That Mayz made me think of a way that I think about how this affects on an organizational level, right? And I also enjoy thinking about things through a biological lens. And so you think about how the body can experience ongoing wounding in different ways, right?
I think of organizations as a living organism, right? So you think about institutions of higher education, and each department or division kind of is a different organ system. You in our bodies, we have hearts and lungs. In, in institutions we have division of student affairs, academic affairs, and all those things, right?
And just like in the body, if something gets wounded, there’s mechanisms in our body to fix that, right? But if those wounds overwhelm that capacity, we have to intervene and apply care. But what I’ve often found is that we don’t do that, to Mayz’s point in, in higher- in the org- on the organizational level.
We’re in a time where that wound is overcoming our capacity to heal without any sort of attention. And so it festers, right? And just because it’s localized maybe in one organ system, in one department or something if left unattended to, it spreads, right? Just like a, a wound in our bodies.
And there’s a lot of work in the the… There’s a book called Organizational Trauma and Healing, and I’ll send that to you, Glenn, to put in the citations. But it’s a really practical book that takes a lot of these concepts and looks at it from the taking- Looks at it from an organizational perspective.
And it makes a lot of sense in how these different things kind of compile on top of each other to create cultures of wimping, right? So it’s this cyc- cyclical piece that becomes a part of the culture in our departments and our institutions.
Glenn DeGuzman: Y- the, you, you brought up that piece about over time, so this idea of what happens over time.
May, is I question if you can dive deeper into this. Higher education leaders, and that I’ll own this, include myself there has been the time when, we’re going through w- we’re, people are going through difficult professional experiences in the workplace, and the response is we would encourage people to be more resilient, practice self-care, right?
We provide them tips and tricks and whatnot to just basically find ways to manage their stress.
But to Jason’s point and to your point about I wanna dive into when you comment about the impact on trust in the workplace, and Jason, about the sustainability. When people experience sustained conflict between what they believe is right and what they f- they feel they are able or required to do there is an impact on them emotionally, psychologically, relationally.
If you can comment on that if you can share more on your perspective on that.
Mays Imad: Yeah. So I teach an entire course-
…
Mays Imad: On resilience.
It’s called Traumatic Stress, Biofeedback, and Intergenerational Resilience, and we examine the notion of resilience from many dimensions. Chief among them is biological.
But I trouble, and I want to trouble the the notion of resilience a little bit. Because the nervous system and our bodies are incredibly adaptive and capable and resilient and that’s one of the remarkable things about being a human being or a plant or, right?
But adaptation, as we know, costs us energy.
Metabolically, it is costly. And so it’s not that we can’t adapt, it’s at what cost and until when, right? Because we don’t have infinite energy, and if we are just working and using the reserve and so on, w- we have t- we reach a point where we are depleted. And it’s not that I fail at being resilient, it’s that I am energetically depleted- because the system I am operating within continues to put the stress and load and so on, on me, that I have to go into, go out of homeostasis, try to get back into homeostasis, and so on.
There’s a really important book that I, and I encourage, in fact, we read it in one of my classes, encourage everyone to read it, by Antonio Damasio called The Strange Order of Things.
And this is where he talks about that, that- Homeostasis, as we know it, is a biological mechanism. Homeostasis gives rise to the feeling, and when, and feelings are really important, and it’s the feelings that then give rise to the in- innovation, the thinking, the so on. I’m simplifying it.
So I guess what I wanna say is sure, I could say I, I look at the h- the human body, the different systems within the human body as an example. I use a lot of biomimicry. And when one system, let’s say the liver is injured, the other systems around the body are focusing on the liver.
They are directing the resources and so on. And that liver can can heal and can get back to functioning, but if we keep putting stress, and the resources will get depleted, and so some- something else has to change. And what I’m saying here is we can, sure, we can go to resilient training and self-care and have massage on campus and those things help, right?
But the root of the problem is not being addressed.
And that will continue to put stress on individuals within the system, which means the system will continue to be stressed and just this vicious cycle and ripple effects-
…
Mays Imad: That ultimately impact our students.
Glenn DeGuzman: So if moral suffering is not simply an individual problem, we’re talking about this system, right? The it’s, there’s pieces that contribute to this. And I think of the system and from a campus perspective then, Jonathan, Jason, if you can start this, but start with, in the response to this, then what is the responsibility then that supervisors, mid-level managers, senior leaders in institutions have?
What is that call-out to them that we must create conditions that support moral recovery rat- rather than just asking professionals, “Just be more resilient”? What do we need, what do we need them to do?
Jonathan O’Brien: Yeah I would say I’ve got a f- there are about three ideas that I can think of.
But for me, the overarching thing, though, is distinguishing individual ethical responsibility from institutional authority and basically placing the responsibility where it belongs, which is on the institutional authority, not so that individuals, in other words, are having to bear that responsibility.
But I’d say the first thing a supervisor can do, name where the decision came from. So if a decision came from the cabinet, the executive cabinet or the president or the board or the legal counsel, be transparent and be say, say where it came from. I think that’s that’s predominantly one way of really saying, “Okay, this is then an institutional responsibility rather than an individual one.”
I think the second thing that supervisors can do is create a space for ethical discussion. And I think people get a little uncomfortable talking about ethical issues. They feel like they have to be a philosopher or like it’s, going to church or something like that. And it, I have to dispel people of that notion.
No, we’re just talking about what is right as a professional and as a human being. What is it that we want to do and be best at? So creating a space, whether that be in one-on-one meetings or ideally, though, and I love what, Maysa’s saying in terms of the community. This is a community i- issue as well.
And so I think in a staff meeting, having a discussion about so what are ways that using the moral positions, for instance what can we stand by? What is our authority in this situation? And then what can we actually accomplish? So strategically what can we do and still ethically be responsible, not accountable, but responsible?
And so I think then one thing I would really love to see for graduate programs as well as supervisors is starting to clarify an ethical scope of practice. And we can’t just lay it out like in our graduate programs as a solitary thing like they do in nursing, for instance, for a scope of practice or therapy for a scope of practice.
It is institutional. It does tie to the context. But I think it’s so important for us to get our, as individual practitioners, to be able to clarify our ethical scope of practice so that we know what we are ethically responsible for and what the institution is, what its authority is in that matter.
So those are the three things I can think of in terms of what supervisors could do.
Jason Lynch: Yeah, no, and I’d underscore all of those. I think that again, sparks off some thoughts for me as well, and particularly around this idea of pr- professional preparation, both from the graduate faculty side and our national organizations like NASPA, ACPA, and whatnot, right?
‘Cause I think that those two entities, our graduate preparation programs and our national organizations sometimes set our professionals up for failure in this regard, ’cause I think that the, the message is that you all are change agents. You are responsible for changing the system, and it turns into this individual sort of moral call to action to…
But then you put these folks in these really complex systems where they have little authority. Their professional socialization tells them that I should be doing this,” but then they can’t, and then they burn out, or they leave the field because they’re so harmed, right? And I think that in our pr- our scope of practice, particularly faculty, and I’ll say the, maybe even faculty that haven’t worked in student affairs, right?
Sometimes we’re really gung-ho about telling students that this is what they need to do, but not giving them the tools to recover or how to navigate complexity as opposed to having a greater ideal around it, right? And I also think that there’s two other kind of thoughts that have come to mind in, in hearing Jonathan speak as well is I’m newly interested in this idea of vocational awe and how it intersects with all of this.
So Fobazi Dr. Fobazi has originated that, that term. It comes out of library science, and it’s just this idea that that your profession, your vocation is above repute, and that it is this high moral standard of a profession. And so of course you should be paid less, of course you should hold up moral ideals, of course you should be s- sacrificing yourself for these ideals.
But is that really true, right? And I do think in student affairs, even the way I was socialized into student affairs the way we talk about our profession is, carries a lot of moral weight, and then that trickles down into all of this. And then I was trying to think of I think my train of thought crashed on that last piece.
It’ll come back up. I’ll- I’ve talked enough.
Glenn DeGuzman: So- May, do you have a comment on that?
Mays Imad: Yeah. I think, what’s coming to me is get to know the people you work with or you supervise. What are their values?
What are n- what’s non-negotiable for them? If we were to…
So for example, I I started bringing this to the classroom. I have a syllabus, and I say to them, when I meet the students, “This is not the final copy. The final copy will happen after a week.” And in this week, what I’m trying to find out is what do you care about? In fact, we do this exercise and, I’m trying to get to know w- what is it that is moving them, what is it that’s non-negotiable for them, w- and then how can I revise my syllabus, my, my approach to…
So I think it’s really important the people we work with, whether we’re working with 2 people or 20 people, what, what matters to them, right? I think the other thing, it’s important for institutions and for leaders to make a distinction between, to distinguish between helping people cope with harm versus- Trying to investigate how can we reduce the harm in the first place.
And I think it’s very important ’cause sometimes we say these things, the system is so this, the system, we can’t change the system. We are the system, right? And there are these micro structural changes that can have incredible ripple effect. Sometimes naming is changing a system and my colleague Jonathan talked about the courage, the moral courage and how important that is.
So I think th- those are really important, and not to be undermined, these micro things, asking people what you care about, what are your non-negotiable, naming things. And then reflecting on what are we asking and normalizing and, I’ll stop here. Yeah.
Glenn DeGuzman: Great.
Jason Lynch: And that, that makes me really think of something that I haven’t considered until I s- I started doing this work, and trying to, i’m trying to find the words. So it made me think about so whose values are we talking about in, or whose moral positionality are we talking about in these conversations, right? ‘Cause I think that I’m gonna go out on a limb and say that all four of us probably have some similar values in what we do as a profession and things like that, right?
But then I think about somebody like Kim Davis, right? So she’s back in the news because she had to pay a bunch of money ’cause she wouldn’t let folks or two men get married, right? I’m married to my husband. I’m very privileged in that I didn’t have to deal with that. But I think about her and that did she experience moral suffering?
‘Cause I, I, while I disagree with her vehemently, I also believe that she holds her values very strongly. And again, disagreeing with those values, but when we’re talking about these conversations of moral suffering and to Mays’s point around getting to know each other’s values, like what I’ve often found, and in Jonathan and I’s work with the physicians, or in even talking at class, like when you’re talking about compliance-oriented people or people in compliance positions, those people end up getting really judged by all the other folks that might have a primary position in somewhere else.
And so I had somebody in class that was talking about the rationale behind it in that I’m complying now because down the road you’re not looking at the future about how this one decision might watershed into something else. And it really made me think in different ways. But as Mays was talking, I was I was like, yes, like if we’re talking to each other about those values, we can dispel some of those assumptions, but at the same time really start to see how complicated all of this really is whenever you’re talking about whose values are being stepped on and and what kind of damage might occur from that or how we prevent that to begin with.
Glenn DeGuzman: I think even the, that courage part of even higher campus leaders who may feel they not, they don’t have the ability to speak and speak to what they value or what their principles are, right? Because, what came up for me and what, and when you all shared was it was actually an article, Mays, that you had written, and it spoke to, we have high-level campus leaders.
They’re being cornered. They’re being cornered. W- they have principles. They got to their level because of their principles, but now they’re being cornered because external things legislation, federal legislation w- I think in even in my world, like DEI initiatives, I have theme programs, right?
These are the different types of things are, that are coming at them that’s forcing them to be, to, to, that things are challenging their beliefs and their convictions. And they have to represent a campus, an institution, yet at the same time, they have their own morals and their own values.
And I see how complex that can be, but sometimes people don’t talk about it, right? And then they’re judged for whatever they choose, and it has an impact on that person in that that suffering that occurs, right? So I guess to some extent, you’re always curious to see, like how does a leader go about in, in, in balancing that?
And how do they talk about things with their teams or their campus or their community, but also recognizing they are representing an institution that maybe they don’t want to talk about that stuff, that we have to follow a certain protocol or procedure or or governance, right?
That was my-
Jonathan O’Brien: Oh, sorry. Yeah. No I think you’re hitting the nail on the head in terms of this was the study that I just recently completed. It’s actually in press right now.
It- it’s constrained responsibility and the accountability gap, basically. So constrained responsibility of ethical professionals is a way of saying exactly what you were talking about, Glenn, is that we have to run a calculus when we’re going through about deciding which of those positions that I talked about taking.
You have to run a calculus that involves a variety of different logics, I call them along with my colleague Lopez, that, people are weighing things like whether or not I’m gonna keep my health insurance. Am I gonna be fired for making these decisions? We’re– there are some states in our union that folks are making very tough decisions about, do I move?
Do I get out of the field? There are also folks, though, to, to Jason’s point about who, who do focus on compliance, and for them it’s the duty of the institution. They were hired to support an institution and to follow its rules and to implement those rules, and they do that without necessarily…
Th- their moral qualm is, am I not being true to the institution and that I work for, and what I’m required to do to keep it out of legal trouble, to keep it out of regulatory punishment by, the federal government or, some other state legislature that’s hostile to them. So there’s a lot of very difficult decisions that people have to walk, and this idea of constrained responsibility is that we can still speak out, we can still challenge what we see as inequities, but we have to do that with the care of being able to make very careful, intentional decisions about what we can document- about what we can report. And in my interviews with a lot of folks in some institutions that were s- really encountering difficult pressure, which we call it coercive compliance by the federal government or state governments, they really are making very difficult decisions about maybe sometimes the best they can do is just document the harm that is occurring and keeping contemporaneous notes- For a time when things will be better.
So I want to put that out there is that we’re in very real times where people are experiencing challenges that speaking out will jeopardize your family’s healthcare, your own healthcare or your future opportunities. And so what can leaders do? Again, it has a lot to do f- from moral positionality with this ability to be able to say, “What is my red line?
At what point do I have to maybe take myself out of the situation?”
What does my exit plan look like?
Glenn DeGuzman: Jonathan, you’re jump- you’re jumping into the, to the next question, which is phenomenal. It’s almost a great lead in. And Mays and and Jason, I’d love for you to add to this to what I think Jonathan is speaking to.
For student affairs professionals who are listening to this podcast or watching it on YouTube, and I know they are because I know I am they’re gonna recognize themselves in this conversation. And I know someone is thinking, “This is exactly what I’ve been feeling, and I just didn’t have the language for it.”
Because quite frankly, until I read your stuff, I didn’t have language for it either. Mays, in your article, you write about imagination, you write about clarity and courage, and community as an important part of the journey from moral injury toward healing and renewal. And what does it mean to move beyond simply enduring moral suffering and begin imagining a different future?
And for that person who sees themselves in this conversation, where might they begin? Jonathan spoke about documenting, but what else can be done?
Mays Imad: Documenting is so important. I’m, I’ve been working on this model of what I call it three phases. The descent, and this is where the fragmentation, the injury, the wound, the dissociation.
But then w- we c- we, we have choice. We don’t, we can’t get, and we shouldn’t get stuck there. There is a pivot, and this is where I talk about the humility, the clarity, the courage to con- that can get us to the becoming, where the imagination is. Now, Jonathan talked about documenting. So I think naming and witnessing are so critical- ’cause it sends a message to my nervous system, to your nervous system that I’m not the only one. This is actually not okay. And and at this point I can’t do anything about it, but I’m gonna witness it and I’m going to, even if you just have one colleague that will just witness with you, I think at…
So you could bear witness to your body, to the moment, to, right? And then so bearing witness, naming, and community, and then what I would say is really trouble the notion of agency. Yes, I can’t, I have to in this case, but then I ask myself, what other small or micro things can I do or smuggle-
That helps bring me back to alignment with my values? Teachers and student service professionals and leaders and are dealing with this all the time and I had to really say to myself, and this notion of smuggling came from one of my mentors, what can I smuggle that would uplift those values that I care so deeply about s- and continue to wrestle with what is being violated?
And I think we can’t lose sight of imagination because when we experience this constant threat, devaluing what we value about and compromising, we can go into shame and guilt and, just this I say the rupture upon rupture and it impacts our sense of imagination.
And ye- which is why we need community, because community can help us imagine what is possible. And in this documenting that Jonathan’s talking about, it helps us think about there will come a time when we get out of this and so the imagination can help us. It’s not just some kind of nice exercise I ask you to imagine a, I don’t know, a purple apple and you imagine it.
No, imagine the impossible and what does it mean to make it possible and even probable. This is… So I think repair is not so much, is not so much returning people to, to operate under the conditions that we were, that were injuring us, but to begin to imagine and just, some ripple to put me into realignment with my values so I could start pushing towards different conditions.
Jason Lynch: And I think I’ll extend on all of that and coming from my context is North Carolina, right? We have that institutional neutrality policy that we’re all operating under, and I teach students from across the state in different levels, and there were, those conversations were coming up about how do we navigate this and fulfill our roles, right?
And I think the, like I think I have two calls, one for- Upper level folks and one for lower level folks. And for the upper level folks, like the VPs, the AVPs you need to talk to your people. And I think that what I’ve noticed is silence has really just taken over the people that are not in those leadership meetings are perceiving that you all don’t care or that you’re keeping your head down, and people are confused about how they should feel, what they’re feeling, what to do with those feelings.
And I think that it’s up to leadership to make sense of that. And I’m not saying that you couldn’t fix it but I think to Jonathan’s point about documentation, to Mays’s point around introspection and just being able to name and identify those pieces you’re the ones that chose to be in these leadership positions.
You’re the ones that are getting paid six figures compared to your staff that are not. So it is your responsibility to help manage some of this. And on the other side, where two things can be true at once, the folks on the lower end need to have some grace for the folks that are in these, these rooms, right?
Again, to the points of my colleagues, those folks have families. Those folks have reputations, homes, mortgages. You don’t know where they came from. So maybe, yes, they make a lot of money, but they might not come from a background where they have generational wealth. Maybe their positionalities. I’ve seen so many women of color being put on the front lines in these other leadership positions and be chastised for not making the decisions that all the, these other folks, the white folks standing behind this person of color is shooting, shoving them out into the, the, the fray.
You need to have some grace for folks, right? They’re humans in these, these leadership positions. And so I think that this is a deeply complex and human issue and that we all have to figure out how to talk about this and show grace in those ways.
Glenn DeGuzman: Yeah. It is a very deeply complex issue, and I can keep asking questions right now, but we are out of time.
I, I think one of the things that, that I’m just gonna add really quickly is that this conversation is extremely important that leaders, that student first practitioners, higher education practitioners need to be engaging in. I think that we’re at a crossroads as a field, as a profession.
And so this podcast is called Student First Now. And I don’t answer this question, but I just gave you my thoughts. So after this conversation that we just had, what are your final thoughts? What are you thinking about? What’s still troubling you, or what are you still pondering about as it relates to today’s conversation?
And if we can go with Mays and then Jonathan and Jason to close us out, I would appreciate that
Mays Imad: I would say sometimes a distress or an injury are not dysfunctions. They are what I say remarkable information our nervous system is telling us that it’s still working. And so there have been times where I told myself, colleagues, students, family members who are really hurting, they feel wounded, they- I say, “Good.
That means your body is working. Your heart is alive.” So I think we have an opportunity. The fact that we feel the wound and the pain, it means we care, and the compass within us is still working and saying, “Hey, hear me out. Listen.” And so I think the last thing I will say is I will bring the poetry of Rumi, Persian poet, who, says that, talks about the wounds and in one of his poem, talks about that the, the wound or the crack is the place where the light can enter- and where healing can begin. So perhaps this is an opportunity for us to say we can’t keep going the way we have been. What else is possible? So this is what I’m, what I’ve been thinking about.
Glenn DeGuzman: Thanks, Mays. I absolutely love that. Thank you for sharing that. Jonathan, what are your final thoughts?
Jonathan O’Brien: Yeah. I think I- I’m strangely optimistic because the fact that we can have this conversation, that we’re talking about this, and that people are doing research in it and discussing it is so important. It, I think that it tells us that people still care very deeply about this work, about students, about their colleagues, and mainly that they haven’t stopped noticing when something feels wrong, when it’s not right.
There’s been a lot of advocacy in our field, but advocacy comes at a cost. Activism comes at a cost, and it’s time for folks to be thinking about that. And I think the challenge, just to conclude, is like we gotta, and I love that Mays talks about this, it is not an isolated burden, that, that moral suffering is a community-based problem.
It is something that we need to discuss. But I also think that as individuals, we still have the power to reflect, we still have the ability to choose our position, as it were and that we can find allies and mentors who share that. And so I’m optimistic.
Glenn DeGuzman: Absolutely. And Jason, close us out.
Jason Lynch: That’s tough after these two,
Glenn DeGuzman: I know. Those were both really good responses.
Jason Lynch: I guess I’ll end with a thought and a pondering or a feeling and a pondering. My feeling, I’ll echo both of my colleagues. I think I’m feeling hopeful. I’m feeling in gratitude to be able to be in space with the folks here and the folks doing this work.
And my pondering, I think, is how do we extend this after this conversation, right? How can we use structures and build structures on a campus, state, or national level to address wellbeing, address this aspect of wellbeing and put it into practice? What are the structures we can create out of this?
I’m hoping something comes out of that.
Glenn DeGuzman: I’ve got something to share with you later on, Jason, but thank you for sharing that. And just, I’m gonna close up today’s episode. A huge thank you to our incredible guests for sharing space with me today. Jason, Mays, Jonathan, thank you for being here.
I wanna thank in advance Nat Ambrosey, our incredible producer, who’s gonna take all this stuff and make it magical, make it look good, and put it on YouTube and onto our podcast. Thank you, Nat. And then our sponsors Evolve. Given the current context of higher education, we need to invest in leaders with the capacity and capabilities to transform their institutions and the future of higher education.
The Evolve Institute for Higher Education Leadership offers four leadership coaching journeys tailored to four different lev- levels of leadership. Each is a three-month journey that includes individual and group coaching, plus a curated curriculum of short asynchronous video modules. This group offers Evolve for leadership teams, and if you’re ready to evolve your leadership voice, visit evolve-institute.com to learn more.
And to everyone listening or watching, have a great day. See you next time. Take care.
Jonathan J. O’Brien & R. Jason Lynch (16 May 2025): Between Policy and Principle: Understanding Moral Suffering in Student Affairs Practitioners, Journal of College and Character, DOI: 10.1080/2194587X.2025.2481567
Jonathan O’Brien (12 Feb 2026): Moral Positionality and Polarization: Leadership Across Ideological Divides, Journal of College and Character, DOI: 10.1080/2194587X.2025.2612359;
Jonathan J. O’Brien (2017) A Typology of Moral Positionality for
Educational Administrators, Journal of College and Character, 18:4, 264-278, DOI:
10.1080/2194587X.2017.1371040;
Imad, M. (2025, August 5). Moral wounds. Inside Higher Ed. https://www.insidehighered.com/opinion/views/2025/08/05/higher-ed-morally-injured-opinion
Jonathan J. O’Brien (2024). Ethical mindfulness in student affairs practice. ACPA Developments, 21(2).
Panelists

Jason Lynch
Jason is an associate professor and program director of higher education and student affairs in the department of counseling, family therapy, and higher education at Appalachian State University. He also serves as the Executive Editor for the Journal of Trauma Studies in Education, and writes about the the nature and impact of trauma in colleges and universities, with specific interest in how trauma and stress manifest in higher education workplaces.

Mays Imad
Mays Imad is an associate professor in the biology department and the director of the neuroscience program at Connecticut College. Previously, she taught for 14 years at Pima Community College, where she also founded the Teaching and Learning Center. Mays is interested in understanding the social determinants of student wellbeing and success and conducts research on emotions, biofeedback, learning, and pedagogy. Her work reflects a deep commitment to justice in and through education. With fervour, she advocates for institutions to pay close attention to trauma and to prioritize healing, repair, and intergenerational wellbeing. She is the founder of the Trauma-Informed Growth Institute for teachers and community members. In addition, she is a Gardner Institute Fellow for Undergraduate Education, an Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) Senior STEM Fellow, a scholar-in-residence at Georgetown University’s Red House, a scholar-in-residence with The Wellbeing Project, and a research fellow with the Centre for the Study of the Afterlife of Violence and the Reparative Quest (AVReQ) at the University of Stellenbosch.

Jonathan O’Brien
Jonathan O’Brien is professor of educational leadership at California State University, Long Beach and a former senior student affairs administrator. He brings more than 35 years of experience in higher education administration and faculty roles to this work. His scholarship examines ethics and moral decision making in higher education, with particular attention to moral suffering, professional responsibility, and the ways institutional and political conditions shape practitioners’ choices. His recent work considers how student affairs professionals respond when their commitments to students, professional values, institutional expectations, and legal requirements come into conflict.
Hosted by

Glenn DeGuzman
Glenn (he/him/his) believes that equitable access to quality education is foundational for people to learn, dream, and thrive. For over 30 years, Glenn has helped students achieve their dreams through a myriad of higher education roles and functions, including residential life, conference services, student life/activities, student unions, cultural centers, campus conduct, and leadership/diversity centers. He has also concurrently held various adjunct and lecturer roles, teaching undergraduate and graduate level courses on topics in higher education and ethnic studies. Glenn has delivered hundreds of keynotes and trainings for national and international institutions, popularized by his creative, humorous, and passionate approaches to teaching and facilitation. Throughout his career, Glenn has received numerous awards and recognitions, including the ACPA Diamond Honoree which highlighted his work in mentoring emerging higher education professionals and students from marginalized communities. Glenn currently serves as the Associate Dean of Students and Director of Residential Life at the University of California, Berkeley. He currently lives in his hometown of Livermore, CA, staying active playing pickleball, attending Comic-Cons, watching his kids compete in Taekwondo, and traveling.


